Toll free phone numbers » USA & Canada: 1-866-413-9809, Europe: 00-800-7099-7099

Cheap hotels in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States of America

Dates: Tuesday 10/23/2018 - Thursday 10/25/2018 (2 Nights) | Rooms: 1 Adults: 2 | Change
Where do you want to stay?
Sort by:
  • Sort by:
  •  
  • Best value
  •  
  • Deals
  •  
  • Price
    • Low to High
    • High to Low
  •  
  • Star rating
    • High to Low
    • Low to High
  •  
  • Alphabetically
  •  
  • Guest ratings
  •  
  • Distance
  •  
Show city map

Why book with us?

Near by destinations

Secured by Thawte
1.

Topping Rose House

 
Bridgehampton, One Bridgehampton - Sag Harbor Turnpike
Topping Rose House Quick View
Near Bridge Gardens
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Full Breakfast
  •  
    Free Wireless Internet
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Outstanding Based on 146 reviews
Hurry! We only have 1 room left
$495
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
2.

Maison Vivienne Southampton

 
Southampton, 136 Main Street
Maison Vivienne Southampton Quick View
Village of Southampton
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Fantastic Based on 4 reviews
Hurry! We only have 5 rooms left
$359
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
3.

The Atlantic Hotel

 
Southampton, 1655 County Road 39
The Atlantic Hotel Quick View
Tuckahoe
  •  
    Free cancellation
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Good Based on 116 reviews
Hurry! We only have 3 rooms left
$108
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
4.

Sea Haven Resort Motel

 
Southampton, 52 Longview Road
Sea Haven Resort Motel Quick View
Shinnecock Hills
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Free Wireless Internet
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Fantastic Based on 5 reviews
Hurry! We only have 2 rooms left
$129
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
5.

Hampton Maid Motel

 
Hampton Bays, 259 E Montauk Hwy
Hampton Maid Motel Quick View
Near Meschutt Beach
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Free Wireless Internet
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Outstanding Based on 99 reviews
Hurry! We only have 3 rooms left
$185
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
6.

Saybrook Point Inn, Marina and Spa

 
Old Saybrook, 2 Bridge St
Saybrook Point Inn, Marina and Spa Quick View
Near General William Hart House
  •  
    Free cancellation
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Outstanding Based on 837 reviews
Hurry! We only have 3 rooms left
$249
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
7.

Water's Edge Resort & Spa

 
Westbrook, 1525 Boston Post Road
Water\'s Edge Resort & Spa Quick View
Near Tanger Outlets
  •  
    Free cancellation
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Great Based on 831 reviews
$215
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
8.

Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook

 
Old Saybrook, 1750 Boston Post Rd
Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook Quick View
Near Tanger Outlets
  •  
    Free cancellation
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Free Parking
  •  
    Full Breakfast
  •  
    Free Wireless Internet
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Great Based on 111 reviews
$59
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
9.

Pier Blue Guesthouse

 
Old Saybrook, 1430 Boston Post Rd
Pier Blue Guesthouse Quick View
Saybrook Manor
  •  
    Free cancellation
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Full Breakfast
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Great Based on 171 reviews
Hurry! We only have 3 rooms left
$69
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
10.

Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook

 
Old Saybrook, 37 Spencer Plain Rd
Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook Quick View
Near Tanger Outlets
  •  
    Free cancellation
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Free Wireless Internet
  •  
    Continental Breakfast
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Great Based on 316 reviews
Hurry! We only have 7 rooms left
$69
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
11.

Liberty Inn

 
Old Saybrook, 55 Springbrook Road
Liberty Inn Quick View
Near Katharine Hepburn Cultural Arts Center
  •  
    Free cancellation
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Great Based on 81 reviews
Hurry! We only have 4 rooms left
$69
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
12.

Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook

 
Old Saybrook, 100 Essex Rd
Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook Quick View
Near Florence Griswold Museum
  •  
    Free cancellation
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Free Parking
  •  
    Full Breakfast
  •  
    Free Wireless Internet
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Fantastic Based on 328 reviews
$149
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
13.

Old Lyme Inn

 
Old Lyme, 85 Lyme Street
Old Lyme Inn Quick View
Near Florence Griswold Museum
  •  
    Free cancellation
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Fantastic Based on 134 reviews
Hurry! We only have 3 rooms left
$219
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
14.

Hyatt Place Long Island East End

 
Riverhead, 451 East Main Street
Hyatt Place Long Island East End Quick View
Near Long Island Aquarium and Exhibition Center
  •  
    Free cancellation
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Free Parking
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Outstanding Based on 1062 reviews
$169
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
15.

The Preston House & Hotel

 
Riverhead, 428 E Main Street
The Preston House & Hotel Quick View
Near Long Island Aquarium and Exhibition Center
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Outstanding Based on 22 reviews
Hurry! We only have 8 rooms left
$259
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
16.

Tidewater Inn

 
Madison, 949 Boston Post Road
Tidewater Inn Quick View
Near Allis-Bushnell House and Museum
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Outstanding Based on 85 reviews
Hurry! We only have 1 room left
$160
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
17.

The Scranton Seahorse Inn

 
Madison, 818 Boston Post Road
The Scranton Seahorse Inn Quick View
Near Scranton Memorial Library
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Full Breakfast
  •  
    Free Wireless Internet
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Perfect Based on 278 reviews
Hurry! We only have 1 room left
$210
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
18.

Madison Beach Hotel

 
Madison, 94 West Wharf Road
Madison Beach Hotel Quick View
Near Deacon John Grave House
  •  
    Free cancellation
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Outstanding Based on 813 reviews
Hurry! We only have 1 room left
$325
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
19.

Copper Beech Inn

 
Ivoryton, 46 Main Street
Copper Beech Inn Quick View
Near Ivoryton Playhouse
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Free Wireless Internet
  •  
    Full Breakfast
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Fantastic Based on 295 reviews
Hurry! We only have 1 room left
$179
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
20.

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

 
Montauk, 290 Old Montauk Highway
Gurney\'s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa Quick View
Near Hither Woods Preserve
  •  
    No resort fees
  •  
    Spa access
  •  
    Lowest Price Guarantee
Fantastic Based on 562 reviews
Hurry! We only have 1 room left
$550
Avg. Nightly Rate
Continue
 Save
Sorry, there are no hotels that match your search. Please change your search criteria to see more hotels.
Want to see more hotels? See all available hotels in Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States of America

We’re so convinced our prices can’t be beat, we’ll guarantee it. If you find a lower rate for your hotel on another site just let us know and we’ll refund the difference to you. Book with us and enjoy total peace of mind!

We promise
 
3